Dickens & Rumi
Cover of ONE OF US IS LYING

book

ONE OF US IS LYING

Karen M. McManus

Strange things are afoot at Bayview High School. (Ages 14 to 17)

Ages 14+Source checked

Why this age? The novel includes a fatal suicide plan, murder investigation, attempted strangulation and assault, drug addiction, bullying, homophobia, infidelity, and emotionally intense family conflict. Its YA prose and themes suit mature teens. This is guidance, not a safety guarantee; reading level and family context may differ.

Quick view

At a glance

Recommended age14+

Strongest cautions

  • Death of a character4/5
  • Frightening scenes4/5
  • Violence4/5

Strongest positives

  • Courage & resilience3/5
  • Diverse representation3/5
  • Good role models3/5

What’s in it?

Products & advertising1/5
Why this rating?

Mentions of common teen technology and social media platforms as part of the modern setting.

Death of a character4/5
Why this rating?

A primary character dies early on; suicide is a central plot point revealed later.

Graphic injury2/5
Why this rating?

Includes descriptions of a fatal allergic reaction and the physical aftermath of an assault, though not excessively graphic.

Strong language2/5
Why this rating?

Contains mild to moderate teen-appropriate profanity and verbal bullying.

LGBTQIA characters3/5
Why this rating?

A main character is revealed to be gay, which is a significant plot point involving coming out and facing prejudice.

Romance3/5
Why this rating?

Features high school romantic relationships, dating, and interpersonal intimacy appropriate for the YA genre.

Frightening scenes4/5
Why this rating?

A death investigation and sustained threats build suspense. The climax includes stalking, a chase through the woods, attempted strangulation, and a rock attack.

Sexual content & nudity1/5
Why this rating?

Includes references to infidelity and teen relationships, but lacks explicit sexual content.

Alcohol or drugs3/5
Why this rating?

Drug addiction affects Nate’s mother, Nate faces a drug-related search, and steroid accusations are part of the investigation.

Violence4/5
Why this rating?

A character is attacked, followed, strangled, and struck with a rock; police custody and threats add sustained danger.

What’s good in it?

Courage & resilience3/5
Why this rating?

Characters confront public exposure, accusations, family conflict, bullying, and physical danger, with Addy resisting Jake and Cooper intervening.

Creativity & curiosity2/5
Why this rating?

The mystery format encourages readers to track clues and consider multiple perspectives.

Diverse representation3/5
Why this rating?

The cast includes varied family circumstances and a gay student whose identity and homophobia are treated as meaningful parts of the plot.

Educational value1/5
Why this rating?

Focuses on narrative entertainment; incidental learning about friendship and social dynamics.

Kindness & empathy3/5
Why this rating?

Friendship and mutual support develop among the suspects, including Nate defending Cooper and Addy helping Janae.

Positive messages3/5
Why this rating?

The story emphasizes solidarity, truth, accountability, resisting harassment, and supporting people facing stigma and crisis.

Good role models3/5
Why this rating?

The protagonists make serious mistakes but grow into supportive friends; Nate defends Cooper and the group seeks legal help.

Family discussion

Talk about it

Conversation starters based on this title’s published content notes.

  1. What did courage look like in this story? Was being brave always the same as being fearless?
  2. How did the story approach death or loss? What helped the characters cope?
  3. Which choice in ONE OF US IS LYING would you have made differently, and why?
  4. Who changed the most in ONE OF US IS LYING, and what caused that change?
Discuss this title with other parents

Community reactions

What families noticed

Add your perspective

Sign in from the homepage to rate this title.

Where to get it

Find in a libraryBuy on Bookshop.orgBuy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and Bookshop.org affiliate, Dickens & Rumi may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

If you liked this

Try something nearby

Related by age fit, format, and catalogue context.

You’re hereONE OF US IS LYING
Dark Lord of DerkholmDiana Wynne Jones · 1998Ages 14+The Secret AdversaryAgatha Christie · 1922Ages 13+Drowned Ammet (Dalemark Quartet, Book 2)Diana Wynne Jones · 1977Ages 12+Cart and Cwidder (The Dalemark Quartet)Diana Wynne Jones · 1975Ages 12+

These content notes are a starting point, not a guarantee. Review the evidence and use your own judgment before choosing a title.

Report an incorrect rating